row column votes student
--- ------ -------- ---------
1 9 ******** joshua <----winner
2 7 ******* melanie
2 1 ***** jamie
1 8 *** esmeralda
2 9 *** terry
1 2 ** andrew
1 4 ** diego c.
2 3 ** joseph
2 5 *
2 6 *
2 8 *
2 2 *
2 4 *